Materials
Six roofing systems, and honest advice about which suits your house.
Half of choosing a roof is ruling things out. Slope, structure, budget and how long you plan to stay narrow it faster than any brochure will.
Side by side
Realistic figures for metro Atlanta. Cost is relative rather than a quote — your roof's pitch, complexity and access move the number considerably.
| System | Service life | Relative cost | Weight | Best suited to |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Architectural asphalt | 25–50 yrs | $ | Light | Almost any pitched home. The regional default. |
| Designer asphalt | 30–40 yrs | $$ | Medium | Slate or shake look without the structural cost. |
| Standing seam metal | 40–70 yrs | $$$ | Light | Low pitches, heavy tree debris, long-term ownership. |
| Concrete / clay tile | 50+ yrs | $$$$ | Very heavy | Homes framed for it, Mediterranean and Spanish styles. |
| Natural slate | 75–150 yrs | $$$$$ | Very heavy | Historic and high-end homes with the structure to carry it. |
| Cedar shake | 25–35 yrs | $$$ | Medium | Character homes where the look justifies the maintenance. |
| TPO / EPDM / mod-bit | 20–30 yrs | $$ | Light | Flat and low-slope roofs, porches, additions, commercial. |
Read up on each system
Asphalt shingles
Architectural, three-tab and designer profiles. What most metro Atlanta homes should be wearing.
Shingle detailMetal roofing
Standing seam and exposed-fastener panels. Long life, low pitch tolerance, sheds pine.
Metal detailTile roofing
Concrete and clay. Beautiful and extremely durable, with a real structural conversation attached.
Tile detailSlate roofing
The longest-lived roof there is, and the one most often ruined by the wrong repair.
Slate detailFlat & low-slope
TPO, EPDM and modified bitumen for porches, additions and commercial buildings.
Membrane detailCedar shake
Real cedar and the synthetic alternatives that imitate it without the maintenance.
Cedar detailThe questions that narrow it fastest
Before anyone shows you a colour board, these four answers usually decide it.
- What's your roof pitch? Below 3:12, shingles are out and you're looking at metal or membrane, whatever the brochure says
- How long will you own the house? A 70-year metal roof on a five-year hold is someone else's asset
- Will the structure carry it? Tile and slate need framing designed or reinforced for the load
- What does the HOA allow? Several communities here restrict profile and colour, and metal is sometimes excluded outright
Ask what happens at the details
Any material can be made to fail at a valley, a wall or a penetration. When you compare bids, compare the flashing and underlayment specifications, not just the surface product.
What neighbors say
A sample of the feedback we hear most often. Full set on our reviews page.
They found the actual leak — a cracked boot, not the whole roof two other companies wanted to sell me. Fixed in an afternoon for a couple hundred dollars.
Dana R. — Peachtree CornersHail came through in March. Home & Hammer met the adjuster on the roof, walked him through what he'd missed, and the claim got approved the second time.
Marcus T. — Johns CreekTear-off Monday, dried in by Tuesday, magnet sweep and gone by Wednesday. My flower beds survived, which honestly surprised me.
Priya S. — RoswellNot sure what your roof needs yet?
A Home & Hammer inspection takes about 45 minutes and ends with photos, a written assessment and a price. If the roof has years left in it, we'll tell you that.