Cedar shake
Beautiful, and honest about what it asks of you.
Real cedar is a genuine commitment in a humid climate. Synthetic shake gives you most of the look and almost none of the maintenance — we'll help you decide which you actually want.
Cedar in a humid climate
Cedar is naturally rot and insect resistant and it weathers to a colour nothing else quite matches. In the Pacific Northwest it thrives. In north Georgia, under heavy tree canopy and long humid summers, it asks considerably more of an owner.
Shade and trapped moisture grow moss and algae. Debris sitting between courses holds water. Without periodic cleaning and treatment, a cedar roof that should give you 30 years gives you 18.
What real cedar needs
- Cleaning and debris removal every year or two, particularly under tree cover
- Treatment with a preservative or fire retardant on a schedule
- Prompt replacement of split or cupped shakes before water finds the gap
- Adequate ventilation both above and below, since cedar needs to dry from both sides
The synthetic alternative
Composite shake products imitate hand-split cedar convincingly, carry 40 to 50 year warranties, come with Class A fire ratings and high impact resistance, and require essentially no maintenance. Colour is consistent rather than the variegated weathering of real cedar — which some people prefer and some don't. On a house under heavy canopy, we'd usually point you here.
Cedar or synthetic
| Natural cedar | Synthetic shake | |
|---|---|---|
| Service life here | 25–35 yrs with maintenance | 40–50 yrs |
| Maintenance | Cleaning and treatment on a schedule | Essentially none |
| Fire rating | Class C, or Class A with treatment | Class A |
| Impact resistance | Moderate; splits under hail | Class 4 on most products |
| Appearance | Weathers and varies, genuinely unique | Consistent; convincing but uniform |
| Weight | Moderate | Light |
| Best for | Owners who want the real thing and will maintain it | Most houses under Georgia canopy |
Common questions
Can you repair my existing cedar roof?
Is cedar a fire risk?
Will my insurer cover cedar?
Can I go from cedar to something else?
Request your free inspection
Tell us about the property and we'll come out with a camera, a moisture meter and a written number.
Cedar roof needing a decision?
We'll assess what's left in it and price both the cedar repair and the synthetic replacement so you can compare properly.